Castan

How to value a startup: five methods with worked examples, and what 2026 rounds were priced at

Investor relations leads this guide

Published 9 November 20267 minute read

Every outside fact read on 9 November 2026
On this page

The short answer

An early-stage startup is valued by agreement, not by formula: the price is what an investor will pay for a share of a company whose future is uncertain, and the methods below are ways to make that number defensible.

Before revenue, investors start from comparables, the price of similar recent rounds, and adjust it with a checklist such as the Berkus or the scorecard method. Once there is revenue and a plausible sale or listing in view, the venture capital method works back from that exit to today. And at pre-seed and seed the price is often set as a valuation cap on a post-money SAFE rather than in a priced round, which makes the cap the number to understand. The five methods, a worked example of each, and the 2026 medians follow, every outside figure read on 9 November 2026.

The five methods, side by side

How early-stage startups are valued
MethodWhen it fitsHow it worksA worked number
ComparablesAny stageThe price of similar recent rounds, adjusted for what is better or worse about youA median post-money SAFE cap of $10 million for rounds of $250,000 to $1 million (Carta, 2025)
Berkus methodBefore revenueUp to $500,000 for each of five risks the company has reducedFive elements adding to $1.3 million, below
Scorecard methodBefore revenueThe regional average pre-money, times a weighted comparison with funded peers1.155 × $2.0 million = $2.31 million, below
Venture capital methodRevenue, and an exit in viewPost-money = the exit value ÷ the return the investor needs$42.5 million ÷ 20 = $2.125 million post-money
SAFE valuation capPre-seed and seedThe cap is the most the SAFE converts at; ownership = investment ÷ the post-money cap$500,000 on a $6.7 million cap is about 7.5%

Before revenue: the Berkus method

Dave Berkus’s method, as described on his site (the page notes an update of November 2016), adds up to $500,000 for each of five elements, each one a risk the company has reduced: a sound idea (basic value and product risk), a prototype (technology risk), a quality management team (execution risk), strategic relationships (market and competitive risk), and product rollout or sales (financial or production risk). The total caps at $2 million before revenue, or $2.5 million after rollout. Berkus aims it at companies with the potential to reach over $20 million in revenue within five years, and writes that it no longer applies once a company has revenue; from then on the revenue is the better guide. The dollar amounts date from when the method was written; read them as proportions and take the scale from current comparables.

A Berkus valuation for a pre-revenue software company, an example
ElementWhat the company hasValue
Sound ideaA defined problem, and five buyers interviewed who would pay to have it solved$400,000
PrototypeA working version used by two pilot customers$350,000
Management teamTwo founders, one of whom has sold to this buyer before$400,000
Strategic relationshipsOne distribution partner in talks, nothing signed$150,000
Rollout or salesNone yet$0
Pre-money valuation$1,300,000

Before revenue: the scorecard method

Bill Payne’s scorecard method, written up on Gust on 20 October 2011, starts from the average pre-money valuation of pre-revenue companies recently funded in the same region, $2.0 million in his article, and weighs the company against them: strength of the management team up to 30%, size of the opportunity 25%, product and technology 15%, competitive environment 10%, marketing, sales channels and partnerships 10%, need for additional investment 5%, and other factors 5%. Each factor is scored as a percentage of the typical funded company, multiplied by its weight, and the results summed; the sum multiplies the baseline. In Payne’s own example the sum is 1.075, which values the company at $2.15 million. The example below uses his weights and baseline with different scores; in 2026 the baseline comes from current rounds like the medians further down.

A scorecard valuation, an example with Payne’s weights and baseline
FactorWeightAgainst the typical funded companyFactor score
Management team30%125%0.375
Size of the opportunity25%150%0.375
Product and technology15%100%0.150
Competitive environment10%75%0.075
Marketing, sales channels and partnerships10%80%0.080
Need for additional investment5%100%0.050
Other5%100%0.050
Sum, times the $2.0 million baseline1.155 × $2.0 million = $2.31 million

With revenue and an exit in view: the venture capital method

Payne’s article on the venture capital method, on Gust on 1 November 2011, gives the two formulas: post-money valuation equals the terminal value divided by the return the investor needs, and pre-money valuation equals post-money minus the investment. The terminal value is what the company could sell for in the year of the exit, estimated from the revenue it would have then, the earnings that revenue would carry, and the price-to-earnings ratio or revenue multiple of its industry. In his software example the two estimates are $45 million at 15 times earnings and $40 million at two times revenue, and he takes the midpoint, $42.5 million. An investor who needs 20 times the money pays a post-money valuation of $42.5 million ÷ 20 = $2.125 million; with $500,000 invested, the pre-money valuation is $1.625 million. The article then lowers that figure for the dilution of the rounds still to come before the exit.

The venture capital method, Payne’s example
StepValue
Revenue in the year of the exit, implied by the multiples$20 million
Earnings in that year, implied by the multiples$3 million
Exit value at 15 times earnings$45 million
Exit value at two times revenue$40 million
Terminal value, the midpoint$42.5 million
The return the investor needs20 times
Post-money valuation$2.125 million
Investment$500,000
Pre-money valuation$1.625 million

What 2026 rounds were priced at

Median valuations, as compiled by Waveup, last reviewed 25 September 2026
RoundMeasureMedianSource and period
Pre-seed SAFEs, $250,000 to $1 millionPost-money valuation cap$10 millionCarta, 2025
Pre-seed SAFEs, $1 million to $2.5 millionPost-money valuation cap$15 millionCarta, 2025
SAFEs above $2.5 millionValuation cap$35 million, up 40% on a year earlierCarta, Q2 2026
Seed, software, priced roundsPost-money valuation$24.3 millionCarta, six months to July 2026
Seed, US, all sectorsPre-money valuation$18.4 millionPitchBook-NVCA, Q1 2026
Seed, US, all sectorsRound size$3.0 millionPitchBook-NVCA, H1 2026
SeedDilution18%Carta, six months to July 2026

A median is where the conversation starts, not your price. The figures above mix sectors and countries, so the comparables worth using are the rounds closest to yours in stage, sector and place.

The SAFE cap is the price in practice

Y Combinator’s post-money SAFE, as described on its documents page, sets a valuation cap: the highest valuation at which the SAFE converts into shares, so that if the next priced round values the company above the cap, the SAFE converts at the cap. On a post-money cap the ownership sold is simply the investment divided by the cap: YC’s own example is $500,000 on a $6.7 million post-money cap, about 7.5%. So the cap you agree works as your price. Before you sign, add every SAFE you have outstanding, since each one sells its own percentage, and look at the result on a fully diluted basis, which is how the next investor will look at it.

How Castan helps

Castan builds and runs your company with you, from the first website to the monthly investor update. It is an AI. Investors value your company; Castan keeps the numbers they value it from, consistent and dated: its investor relations role drafts the monthly investor update from the statements and the pitch deck from everything on record, revenue by month, customers and runway among them, and marks a gap wherever nothing is on record rather than inventing a figure. Its business counsel writes the business definition with you and weighs the odds of the idea with the sources they rest on, which is the honest version of the opportunity and the competition a scorecard asks you to rate.

Questions people ask

How do you value a startup with no revenue?

Start from comparables, the price of similar recent rounds in your stage, sector and region, then adjust with a checklist such as the Berkus method (up to $500,000 for each of five risks reduced) or the scorecard method (the regional average times a weighted comparison). At pre-seed the number is often agreed as a SAFE valuation cap.

What is the difference between pre-money and post-money valuation?

Pre-money is the value before the new money comes in; post-money is pre-money plus the investment. The investor’s share is the investment divided by the post-money valuation: $500,000 at a $5 million post-money is 10%.

How much equity should I give up in a seed round?

The median seed dilution on Carta was 18% in the six months to July 2026, as compiled by Waveup. Your own figure follows from the amount you raise divided by the post-money valuation you agree.

Is a SAFE valuation cap the same as a valuation?

Not formally: it is the highest valuation at which the SAFE converts. In practice, on a post-money SAFE the ownership sold is the investment divided by the cap, so the cap works as the price unless the next round is priced lower.

Sources

  1. 1Dave Berkus: the Berkus method, valuing an early-stage investment, updated November 2016five elements, up to $500,000 each; $2 million before revenue, $2.5 million after rollout
  2. 2Gust, Bill Payne: scorecard valuation methodology, 20 October 2011the factors and their weights; the $2.0 million baseline; his example at 1.075
  3. 3Gust, Bill Payne: the venture capital method, 1 November 2011post-money = terminal value ÷ return; the $42.5 million, 20 times example
  4. 4Y Combinator: SAFE financing documentsthe post-money valuation cap; $500,000 on a $6.7 million cap is about 7.5%
  5. 5Waveup: seed round benchmarks 2026, last reviewed 25 September 2026medians compiled from Carta and PitchBook-NVCA
  6. 6Castan: investor relations, the update and the deck

Prices and terms at other companies change over time. Every figure on this page carries the day it was read, and the page it was read on is linked above. If one has moved since, write to hello@castan.ai and the page is corrected. General information, not tax, legal or accounting advice.